SOUTH AFRICA POLITICS: Baleka Mbete Cannot Remain Fair, Impartial

Politicoscope
By Politicoscope May 15, 2017 12:49

Related Coverage You May Like


Current Political Article Highlights


Speaker of parliament Baleka Mbete cannot fulfil her obligation to remain fair and impartial because her position as ANC national chairman creates “irreconcilable conflict of interest”.

Continue below with the full current political topic.

SOUTH AFRICA POLITICS: Baleka Mbete Cannot Remain Fair, Impartial

Speaker of parliament Baleka Mbete cannot fulfil her obligation to remain fair and impartial because her position as ANC national chairman creates “irreconcilable conflict of interest”.

So said the Council for the Advancement for the SA Constitution, which last week applied to be allowed amicus curae (friend of the court) in a motion brought before the Constitutional Court.

The motion is to force a secret vote in parliament to decide the upcoming motion of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma. The matter will be heard today.

Casac argues that although Mbete’s duties as speaker do not preclude her from being a member of a political party, she is required to perform the functions of that office “fairly and impartially”.

The organisation wishes to join the application brought by the United Democratic Movement, supported by other parties, for a secret vote and argues that an MP’s obligation to the constitution comes before party mandates.

“The speaker is no mere member of the ruling party, she is its national chairman. She is thus subject to an irreconcilable conflict of interest that makes her obligation in respect of a no-confidence motion impossible to perform.

“She cannot at once seek, as ANC chairman, to ensure that her party speaks with one voice and, as speaker, to act impartially in ensuring that all members are entitled to vote according to their constitutional obligations.”

Casac submits that if the court finds that the constitution permits but does not require a secret ballot, it should direct the speaker to arrange for a vote by secret ballot.

Zuma filed an affidavit on Thursday opposing the UDM’s application, saying that voting by way of an open ballot is not unconstitutional, as claimed by the UDM.

The president dismissed as spurious the UDM’s claim that MPs participating in an openly held motion of no-confidence vote could be intimidated or suffer career-limiting consequences.

In her affidavit Mbete said she is “personally not averse to having a motion of no confidence in the president being decided by secret ballot”. She argued that the UDM should have approached parliament’s rules committee.

“This application has no merit. it is calculated to embroil this court in political controversy in a matter that involved a violation of the principle of separation of powers and it is grounded on the assumption that the members of the National Assembly, particularly the ANC, are weak-kneed, timid, cowardly, unprincipled and spineless persons, which assumption I am not prepared to make,” said Mbete.

– Times Live


Up Next on Politicoscope

Share this Article: "SOUTH AFRICA POLITICS: Baleka Mbete Cannot Remain Fair, Impartial"
Since You’re Here, We Would Like to ask You for Help
There are more readers worldwide reading the Politicoscope daily news content than ever before. Unlike many other news media organisations that charge their readers subscription fees for the same daily news content and features we offer you for free, we do not charge all our readers to pay any fee. We depend on online advertising to generate the revenues to fund all these great news content and exclusive features provided to you for free. Currently, advertising revenues are quickly falling which is affecting our ability to offer you free online news content.
If everyone who reads our news content, likes it and helps to support it, we can have future guarantee to offer you with the best daily news content and other amazing features, all for free.
"I visit Politicoscope everyday to read my daily news in world politics. I'm glad it's all for free. On my part, I'm happy to donate monthly so as to continue enjoying these free content because it's actually a small amount from me compared to paid subscriptions by other news organisations. I want to help Politicoscope grow more so that I and other readers can continue to have access to free and exclusive daily online news." - Denise H., from LA, USA.
Help keep Politicoscope alive and grow stronger for you.

Donate Online Today


Politicoscope
By Politicoscope May 15, 2017 12:49

You May Also Like


Since You’re Here, We Would Like to ask You for Help

There are more readers worldwide reading the Politicoscope daily news content than ever before. Unlike many other news media organisations that charge their readers subscription fees for the same daily news content and features we offer you for free, we do not charge all our readers to pay any fee. We depend on online advertising to generate the revenues to fund all these great news content and exclusive features provided to you for free. Currently, advertising revenues are quickly falling which is affecting our ability to offer you free online news content.
If everyone who reads our news content, likes it and helps to support it, we can have future guarantee to offer you with the best daily news content and other amazing features, all for free.
"I visit Politicoscope everyday to read my daily news in world politics. I'm glad it's all for free. On my part, I'm happy to donate monthly so as to continue enjoying these free content because it's actually a small amount from me compared to paid subscriptions by other news organisations. I want to help Politicoscope grow more so that I and other readers can continue to have access to free and exclusive daily online news." - Denise H., from LA, USA.
Help keep Politicoscope alive and grow stronger for you.

What's on Your Mind?